林内空间结构特征对视觉感知与偏好的影响——基于树木排列方式、分枝特性和枝下高特征分析

编号 lyqk011072

中文标题 林内空间结构特征对视觉感知与偏好的影响——基于树木排列方式、分枝特性和枝下高特征分析

作者 陈冰晶  李树华 

作者单位 1. 天津理工大学艺术学院 天津 300384;
2. 清华大学建筑学院 北京 100083

期刊名称 中国城市林业 

年份 2023 

卷号 21

期号 3

栏目名称 研究论文 

中文摘要 针对植物景观林内视觉偏好中关于空间结构特征的争议点与空白点,以林内空间水平结构中的树木排列方式、垂直结构中的枝下高,顶面结构中的分枝特性3个特征因子进行L₉(3³)正交试验,通过仿真建模和虚拟现实技术进行控制变量研究。结果表明:1)排列方式中均匀分布的评分低于随机与团状分布,分枝特性中合轴分枝的评分低于单轴分枝与混合分枝,枝下高等级变化对视觉偏好没有影响;2)评分最优的林内空间为水平结构上团状分布,分枝特性为单轴分枝,枝下高为中等;评分最劣的林内空间为水平结构上均匀分布,分枝特性为合轴分枝,枝下高为较高;3)3个结构特征对林内空间视觉偏好的影响大小为分枝特性>排列方式>枝下高;4)排列方式是影响眼动水平距离最大的因素,分枝特性是对垂直距离、眼跳与注视次数影响最大的因素。因此,在营建景观林内空间时,应注重树种分枝特性的选择,优先考虑单轴分枝的植物,并尽量避免均匀分布。

关键词 植物景观  风景林  视觉质量评估  虚拟现实  眼动追踪 

基金项目 国家自然科学基金面上项目(51978364)

英文标题 Effects of Spatial Structure in Forest on Visual Perception and Preference: Based on Attributes Analysis of Tree Distribution, Branching Habit and Trunk Height

作者英文名 Chen Bingjing, Li Shuhua

单位英文名 1. School of Art & Design, Tianjin University of Technology, Tianjin 300384, China;
2. School of Architecture, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100083, China

英文摘要 In view of the controversies and gaps in spatial structure features of visual preference in landscape woodland, this study selects three spatial structural attributes of woodland, i.e., distribution of trees in horizontal structure, trunk height in vertical structure, and branching habit in ceiling structure, to conduct an L₉(3³) orthogonal experiment and carry out the quantitative research on control variables by using simulation modelling and virtual reality technology. The results indicate:1) The ratings of regular distribution are lower than that of random or aggregated distribution, and the ratings of decurrent branching are lower than that of excurrent branching and mixes of branching characteristics. The trunk heights selected in this experiment have no effect on visual preference; 2) The woodland spatial structures preferred are aggregated distribution, excurrent branching, and medium trunk height; 3) The three spatial structures can be ranked as branching habit > horizontal distribution > trunk height, in terms of their effects on woodland visual preference; and 4) The horizontal distribution is the most important factor to affect the distance of eye movements, while the branching habit is the largest factor to affect the vertical distances, saccades and fixations. In this sense, when establishing the landscape woodland space, we should attach importance to the selection of tree branching habits, especially the trees with excurrent branching, and avoid the regular distribution if possible.

英文关键词 plantscape;landscape forest;visual quality evaluation;virtual reality;eye movements

起始页码 43

截止页码 51

投稿时间 2021/12/30

作者简介 陈冰晶(1990-),女,博士,研究方向为植物景观设计与环境心理学。E-mail:chen_bingjing@foxmail.com

通讯作者介绍 李树华(1963-),男,博士,教授、博士生导师,研究方向为园林康养与园艺疗法、植物景观与生态修复。E-mail:lishuhua912@163.com

E-mail lishuhua912@163.com

DOI 10.12169/zgcsly.2021.12.30.0002

参考文献 [1] 俞晓凌,廖邦洪,王道模,等.龙门山国家地质公园天台山风景游憩林空间结构分析与美景度评价[J].林业科学,2011,47(7):50-56.
[2] 艾婧文,刘健,余坤勇,等.群落特征和林分空间结构对森林公园景观美学质量贡献率及影响因子[J].浙江农林大学学报,2017,34(6):1087-1094.
[3] DRAMSTAD W E,TVEIT M S,FJELLSTAD W J,et al.Relationships between visual landscape preferences and map-based indicators of landscape structure[J].Landscape and Urban Planning,2006,78(4):465-474.
[4] 崔义.城市森林林内景观质量通用评价指标体系及量化评价技术研究[D].北京:北京林业大学,2020.
[5] 梅光义,孙玉军.基于SBE法的杉木风景游憩林的评价及经营技术[J].中南林业科技大学学报,2012,32(8):28-32.
[6] 牛君丽.北京风景游憩林质量评价的指标体系研究[D].北京:北京林业大学,2008.
[7] 欧阳勋志,廖为明,彭世揆.天然阔叶林景观质量评价及其垂直结构优化技术[J].应用生态学报,2007,18(6):1388-1392.
[8] 谷晓萍,谷丽萍,周永斌,等.棋盘山风景区森林林内景观质量评价研究[J].西部林业科学,2008,37(4):49-55.
[9] 陈鑫峰,贾黎明.京西山区森林林内景观评价研究[J].林业科学,2003,39(4):59-66.
[10] 陈勇,孙冰,廖绍波,等.深圳市城市森林林内景观的美景度评价[J].林业科学,2014,50(8):39-44.
[11] 杨鑫霞,亢新刚,杜志,等.基于SBE法的长白山森林景观美学评价[J].西北农林科技大学学报(自然科学版),2012,40(6):86-90,98.
[12] 赵凯,李金航,刘海轩,等.北京山区侧柏人工林林内景观质量分级技术[J].浙江农林大学学报,2019,36(03):557-564.
[13] RUDDELL E J,GRAMANN J H,RUDIS V A,et al.The psychological utility of visual penetration in near-view forest scenic-beauty models[J].Environment and Behavior,1989,21(4):393-412.
[14] 梁爽,张洁,戚继忠,等.次生林为主的自然风景林林内景观质量评价[J].南京林业大学学报(自然科学版),2015,39(6):119-124.
[15] 王娜,钟永德,黎森.基于SBE法的城郊森林公园森林林内景观美学质量评价[J].西北林学院学报,2017,32(1):308-314.
[16] 杨阳,唐晓岚.南京市紫金山国家森林公园风景林景观的视觉质量评价及因子分析[J].中国园林,2020,36(6):135-140.
[17] 章志都.京郊低山风景游憩林质量评价及调控关键技术研究[D].北京:北京林业大学,2010.
[18] 周璞,王瑞辉,周阳超,等.湘东中山区风景游憩林林内景观质量评价与分析[J].林业资源管理,2017(3):91-97.
[19] HULL R B,BUHYOFF G J,CORDELL H K.Psychophysical models:an example with scenic beauty perceptions of roadside pine forests[J].Landscape Journal,1987,6(2):113-122.
[20] 周阳超,王瑞辉,周璞,等.湘东常绿阔叶林林内景观质量评价与分析[J].林业资源管理,2019(3):163-168.
[21] 艾婧文,刘健,余坤勇,等.群落特征和林分空间结构对森林公园景观美学质量贡献率及影响因子[J].浙江农林大学学报,2017,34(6):1087-1094.
[22] 史琛媛,张志伟,魏浩亮,等.冀北山地不同疏伐密度下油松风景林美景度的研究[J].河北林果研究,2015,30(4):335-339.
[23] BOOTH N K.Basic elements of landscape architectural design[M].Long Grove:Waveland Press Incorporated,1989.
[24] VALTCHANOV D,BARTON K R,ELLARD C.Restorative effects of virtual nature settings[J].Cyberpsychology,Behavior,and Social Networking,2010,13(5):503-512.
[25] 邹宁,李运远,胡楠.校园植物群落特征对滞尘能力及美景度的影响[J].中国城市林业,2022,20(5):16-22.
[26] SUN M,HERRUP K,SHI B,et al.Changes in visual interaction:viewing a Japanese garden directly,through glass or as a projected image[J].Journal of Environmental Psychology,2018,60:116-121.
[27] 陈勇,孙冰,罗水兴.深圳城市森林林外近景观美景度评价[J].中国城市林业,2022,20(5):23-28.
[28] KULIGA S F,THRASH T,DALTON R C,et al.Virtual reality as an empirical research tool:exploring user experience in a real building and a corresponding virtual model[J].Computers,Environment and Urban Systems,2015,54:363-375.
[29] HEYDARIAN A,CARNEIRO J P,GERBER D,et al.Immersive virtual environments versus physical built environments:a benchmarking study for building design and user-built environment explorations[J].Automation in Construction,2015,54:116-126.
[30] GAO T,ZHANG T,ZHU L,et al.Exploring psychophysiological restoration and individual preference in the different environments based on virtual reality[J].International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,2019,16(17):3102.
[31] CHEN B J,GONG C,LI S H.Looking at buildings or trees?Association of human nature relatedness with eye movements in outdoor space[J].Journal of Environmental Psychology,2022,80:101756.
[32] TABRIZIAN P,BARAN P K,SMITH W R,et al.Exploring perceived restoration potential of urban green enclosure through immersive virtual environments[J].Journal of Environmental Psychology,2018,55:99-109.
[33] 惠刚盈,胡艳波,徐海.森林空间结构的量化分析方法[J].东北林业大学学报,2005,33(增刊):45-48,60.
[34] 包战雄.风景林景观质量评价与经营研究[D].福州:福建农林大学,2002.
[35] DANIEL T C,BOSTER R S.Measuring landscape esthetics:the scenic beauty estimation method (Research paper RM-USDA Forest Service) [R].U.S.Department of Agriculture,Forest Service,Rocky Mountain Forest and Range Experiment Station,1976.
[36] GIERGICZNY M,CZAJKOWSKI M,ẐYLICZ T,et al.Choice experiment assessment of public preferences for forest structural attributes[J].Ecological Economics,2015,119:8-23.
[37] 万欣,王磊,江浩,等.森林景观质量研究现状与展望[J].江苏林业科技,2017,44(6):43-46,51.
[38] TAHVANAINEN L,TYRVÄINEN L,IHALAINEN M,et al.Forest management and public perceptions:visual versus verbal information[J].Landscape and urban planning,2001,53(1):53-70.
[39] WANG R H,ZHAO J W,MEITNER M J.Urban woodland understory characteristics in relation to aesthetic and recreational preference[J].Urban Forestry and Urban Greening,2017,24:55-61.
[40] PORTERA M,BARTALESI L.Aesthetic preferences:an evolutionary approach[M]//PANEBIANCO F,SERRELLI E.Understanding cultural traits:a multidisciplinary perspective on cultural diversity.Cham:Springer International Publishing,2016.
[41] APPLETON J.The experience of landscape[M].London:John Wiley and Sons,1975.
[42] 惠刚盈,胡艳波.角尺度在林分空间结构调整中的应用[J].林业资源管理,2006(2):31-35.
[43] 李俊熠.进化心理学视角下的植物景观偏好研究[D].杭州:浙江农林大学,2020.
[44] 贾黎明,李效文,郝小飞,等.基于SBE法的北京山区油松游憩林抚育技术原则[J].林业科学,2007(9):144-149.
[45] 毛斌,徐程扬,李翠翠,等.不同修枝强度对侧柏、油松人工林林内景观美景度的影响[J].西北林学院学报,2013,28(3):123-125,205.
[46] 章志都,徐程扬,龚岚,等.基于SBE法的北京市郊野公园绿地结构质量评价技术[J].林业科学,2011,47(8):53-60.
[47] YIN J,ZHU S H,MACNAUGHTON P,et al.Physiological and cognitive performance of exposure to biophilic indoor environment[J].Building and Environment,2018,132:255-262.

PDF全文 浏览全文