国外基于自然的解决方案(NbS)研究进展

编号 lyqk011570

中文标题 国外基于自然的解决方案(NbS)研究进展

作者 徐琳琳  胡文浩  徐文辉 

作者单位 浙江农林大学风景园林与建筑学院 杭州 311300

期刊名称 中国城市林业 

年份 2024 

卷号 22

期号 3

栏目名称 综述 

中文摘要 文章基于CiteSpace软件和Web of Science核心数据库,对国外基于自然的解决方案(NbS)文献进行梳理和分析,以期为该领域研究及其在中国本土化的应用提供参考。结果表明:1)国外NbS研究处于快速发展阶段,2016年后发文量显著提升,研究集中分布在北美、欧洲等地区,欧盟国家汇集了主要的研究机构,但尚未出现具有影响力的学者;2)NbS的知识研究基础以评估框架研究和实践案例研究为主;3)NbS研究5大热点为城市再生、绿色空间管理、气候适应与变化减缓、海岸韧性以及参与式规划和治理,该领域早期聚焦于与之相关的概念研究,而后转向具体方向领域的实证研究;4)NbS研究重点为蓝绿基础设施建设、生态系统恢复以及海岸灾害防御3大领域。在此基础上,对NbS研究提出展望,即未来应重视概念辨析、加强实证研究、注重利益相关者间权衡,以及促进在发展中国家推广。

关键词 基于自然的解决方案  文献计量  研究综述 

基金项目 浙江省自然科学基金项目(LGN20C160003)

英文标题 Research Progress Abroad in Nature-based Solutions (NbS)

作者英文名 Xu Linlin, Hu Wenhao, Xu Wenhui

单位英文名 College of Landscape and Architecture, Zhejiang Agriculture & Forestry University, Hangzhou 311300, China

英文摘要 Using the CiteSpace and Web of Science, the paper reviews literature abroad on nature-based solutions (NbS), in order to provide references for the research and its localized application in China. The results indicate:1) The research on NbS abroad is in a rapid development phase, and the number of publications has increased significantly since 2016. The research is concentrated in North America and Europe, among which the research institutions in the EU countries make contribution the most, but there are no influential scholars; 2) The research on NbS mainly consists of assessment framework research and case study; 3) The five hotspots in the research on the NbS are urban renewal, green space management, climate adaptation and climate change mitigation, coastal resilience and participatory planning & governance, and the research shifts its focus from conceptual studies to empirical studies in specific fields; and 4) The NbS research focuses on three study areas, including blue-green infrastructure construction, ecosystem restoration and coastal disaster prevention. On this basis, we propose an outlook for NbS research, i.e., paying attention to concept discrimination, boosting the empirical research, emphasizing the trade-offs among stakeholders, and promoting the NBS in developing countries.

英文关键词 nature-based solutions;literature metrology;research review

起始页码 176

截止页码 183

投稿时间 2022/12/13

作者简介 徐琳琳(1997-),女,硕士生,研究方向为风景园林规划与设计。E-mail:461980524@qq.com

通讯作者介绍 徐文辉(1968-),男,硕士,教授,研究方向为风景园林规划与设计。E-mail:392428985@qq.com

E-mail 392428985@qq.com

DOI 10.12169/zgcsly.2022.12.13.0001

参考文献 [1] BRINK E,AALDERS T,ÁDÁM D,et al.Cascades of green:a review of ecosystem-based adaptation in urban areas[J].Global Environmental Change,2016,36:111-123.
[2] DE VRIEND H,VAN KONINGSVELD M,AARNINKHOF S.'Building with nature’:the new Dutch approach to coastal and river works[J].Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers-Civil Engineering,2014,167(1):18-24.
[3] MAES J,JACOBS S.Nature-based solutions for Europe's sustainable development[J].Conservation Letters,2017,10(1):121-124.
[4] COHEN-SHACHAM E,JANZEN C,MAGINNIS S,et al.Nature-based solutions to address global societal challenges[R].Gland,Switzerland:IUCN,2016.
[5] 大自然保护协会.基于自然的解决方案研究与实践[M].北京:中国环境出版集团,2021.
[6] COHEN-SHACHAM E,ANDRADE A,DALTON J,et al.Core principles for successfully implementing and upscaling Nature-based Solutions[J].Environmental Science & Policy,2019,98:20-29.
[7] VOJINOVIC Z,ALVES A,GÓMEZ J P,et al.Effectiveness of small-and large-scale Nature-Based Solutions for flood mitigation:the case of Ayutthaya,Thailand[J].Science of the Total Environment,2021,789:147725.
[8] MUBEEN A,RUANGPAN L,VOJINOVIC Z,et al.Planning and suitability assessment of large-scale nature-based solutions for flood-risk reduction[J].Water Resources Management,2021,35(10):3063-3081.
[9] NESSHÖVER C,ASSMUTH T,IRVINE K N,et al.The science,policy and practice of nature-based solutions:an interdisciplinary perspective[J].Science of the Total Environment,2017,579:1215-1227.
[10] RAYMOND C M,FRANTZESKAKI N,KABISCH N,et al.A framework for assessing and implementing the co-benefits of nature-based solutions in urban areas[J].Environmental Science & Policy,2017,77:15-24.
[11] KEESSTRA S,NUNES J,NOVARA A,et al.The superior effect of nature based solutions in land management for enhancing ecosystem services[J].Science of the Total Environment,2018,610/611:997-1009.
[12] SEDDON N,CHAUSSON A,BERRY P,et al.Understanding the value and limits of nature-based solutions to climate change and other global challenges[J].Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series B,Biological Sciences,2020,375(1794):20190120.
[13] FRANTZESKAKI N.Seven lessons for planning nature-based solutions in cities[J].Environmental Science & Policy,2019,93:101-111.
[14] GUO P,LI Q,GUO H D,et al.A bibliometric and visual analysis of global urban resilience research in 2011-2020:development and hotspots[J].Sustainability,2021,14(1):229.
[15] FERREIRA V,BARREIRA A P,LOURES L,et al.Stakeholders' perceptions of appropriate nature-based solutions in the urban context[J].Journal of Environmental Management,2021,298:113502.
[16] RUANGPAN L,VOJINOVIC Z,PLAVŠIĆ J,et al.Incorporating stakeholders' preferences into a multi-criteria framework for planning large-scale Nature-Based Solutions[J].Ambio,2021,50(8):1514-1531.
[17] FORIO M A E,BURDON F J,DE TROYER N,et al.A Bayesian Belief Network learning tool integrates multi-scale effects of riparian buffers on stream invertebrates[J].Science of the Total Environment,2022,810:152146.
[18] LI L,CHESHMEHZANGI A,CHAN F K S,et al.Mapping the research landscape of nature-based solutions in urbanism[J].Sustainability,2021,13(7):3876.
[19] ZÖLCH T,HENZE L,KEILHOLZ P,et al.Regulating urban surface runoff through nature-based solutions–an assessment at the micro-scale[J].Environmental Research,2017,157:135-144.
[20] SÁNCHEZ-ALMODÓVAR E,OLCINA-CANTOS J,MARTI-TALAVERA J.Adaptation strategies for flooding risk from rainfall events in southeast Spain:case studies from the bajo segura,Alicante[J].Water,2022,14(2):146.
[21] VIEIRA J,MATOS P,MEXIA T,et al.Green spaces are not all the same for the provision of air purification and climate regulation services:The case of urban parks[J].Environmental Research,2018,160:306-313.
[22] WU C Y,LI J X,WANG C F,et al.Understanding the relationship between urban blue infrastructure and land surface temperature[J].Science of the Total Environment,2019,694:133742.
[23] MARANDO F,SALVATORI E,FUSARO L,et al.Removal of PM₁₀ by forests as a nature-based solution for air quality improvement in the metropolitan city of Rome[J].Forests,2016,7(7):150.
[24] LAKHO F H,VERGOTE J,KHAN H I U H,et al.Total value wall:Full scale demonstration of a green wall for grey water treatment and recycling[J].Journal of Environmental Management,2021,298:113489.
[25] REYHANI M,SANTOLINI E,TORREGGIANI D,et al.Assessing the environmental performance of plastic-based and felt-based green wall systems in a life-cycle perspective[J].Science of the Total Environment,2022,822:153648.
[26] ZENG Y W,SARIRA T V,CARRASCO L R,et al.Economic and social constraints on reforestation for climate mitigation in Southeast Asia[J].Nature Climate Change,2020,10:842-844.
[27] SMITH C C,HEALEY J R,BERENGUER E,et al.Old-growth forest loss and secondary forest recovery across Amazonian countries[J].Environmental Research Letters,2021,16(8):085009.
[28] BEYER F,JANSEN F,JURASINSKI G,et al.Drought years in peatland rewetting:rapid vegetation succession can maintain the net CO₂ sink function[J].Biogeosciences,2021,18(3):917-935.
[29] FRANTZESKAKI N,MCPHEARSON T,COLLIER M J,et al.Nature-based solutions for urban climate change adaptation:linking science,policy,and practice communities for evidence-based decision-making[J].BioScience,2019,69(6):455-466.
[30] VAN WESENBEECK B K,WOLTERS G,ANTOLÍNEZ J AA,et al.Wave attenuation through forests under extreme conditions[J].Scientific Reports,2022,12(1):1884.
[31] FAIRCHILD T P,BENNETT W G,SMITH G,et al.Coastal wetlands mitigate storm flooding and associated costs in estuaries[J].Environmental Research Letters,2021,16(7):074034.
[32] MORRIS R L,GRAHAM T D J,KELVIN J,et al.Kelp beds as coastal protection:Wave attenuation of Ecklonia radiata in a shallow coastal bay[J].Annals of Botany,2020,125(2):235-246.
[33] MAZA M,LARA J L,LOSADA I J.Predicting the evolution of coastal protection service with mangrove forest age[J].Coastal Engineering,2021,168:103922.
[34] WARYSZAK P,GAVOILLE A,WHITT AA,et al.Combining gray and green infrastructure to improve coastal resilience:Lessons learnt from hybrid flood defenses[J].Coastal Engineering Journal,2021,63(3):335-350.
[35] KUMAR P,DEBELE S E,SAHANI J,et al.An overview of monitoring methods for assessing the performance of nature-based solutions against natural hazards[J].Earth-Science Reviews,2021,217:103603.
[36] CHAUSSON A,TURNER B,SEDDON D,et al.Mapping the effectiveness of nature-based solutions for climate change adaptation[J].Global Change Biology,2020,26(11):6134-6155.
[37] VAN WESENBEECK B K,MULDER J P M,MARCHAND M,et al.Damming deltas:a practice of the past?Towards nature-based flood defenses[J].Estuarine,Coastal and Shelf Science,2014,140:1-6.

PDF全文 浏览全文